Court: Silence on Verification Can Void a No-Fault Claim
In Chapa Prods., Corp. v MVAIC (2026 NY Slip Op 00342), the Appellate Division addressed a question that reaches into the daily mechanics of no-fault billing: what happens when a provider simply does not answer an insurer's verification demand. The court's answer is unforgiving to providers.
The decision holds that no denial is required when a medical provider or injured person fails to respond to verification demands within 120 days of the first verification request. Under the court's reading of Regulation 68, once that 120-day window passes without a response, the claim is deemed withdrawn by operation of the regulation itself — the insurer does not need to issue a formal denial to defeat it.
That is a meaningful shift in leverage. In the past, a provider could often count on the denial as a procedural checkpoint — a document to contest, a date to argue about, a defense that the insurer failed to follow the rules. Chapa closes that door for unanswered verification: there is no denial to attack because none was required.
Verification requests are routine in no-fault. Carriers use them to ask for records, exam findings, ownership information, and documentation of medical necessity. Historically some providers treated slow or partial responses as low-risk. After Chapa, a request that sits unanswered past 120 days does not just weaken the claim — it can end it.
The operational lesson is direct and cheap to implement: calendar every verification request the day it arrives, assign an owner, and respond in full within the window. Partial or late responses are a gray area; silence is now essentially fatal. In a system where most disputes are decided on procedure, answering verification on time is one of the highest-return habits a no-fault biller can build.