No-Fault · Arbitration

Confirming a Master Award Carries a Second Fee Award

April 29, 2026  ·  New York

A provider billed as assignee, the carrier denied, and the file went the full distance. An arbitrator awarded $15,219.04 plus interest on May 8, 2023, and a master arbitrator affirmed that award on August 1, 2023. In October 2023 the provider commenced a CPLR article 75 proceeding in Supreme Court, Nassau County to confirm. The carrier did not answer or oppose the petition. On April 29, 2026 the Appellate Division, Second Department reversed the judgment insofar as appealed from — which is the part a billing office should read closely, because the reversal was about fees, not about the underlying bill.

The first correction is arithmetic and worth committing to memory. Under 11 NYCRR 65-4.6(d), fees for an arbitration and a master arbitration in which the applicant ultimately prevailed are "20 percent of the total amount of first-party benefits and any additional first-party benefits, plus interest thereon for each applicant per arbitration or court proceeding, subject to a maximum fee of $1,360." The Supreme Court had entered $1,000. The carrier conceded the point on appeal and the Appellate Division fixed the figure at $1,360. Twenty percent of a $15,219.04 award runs well past the cap, so on any award of roughly $6,800 or more the number is simply the cap — check the judgment against it rather than assuming the calculation was done.

The second holding is the one that changes practice. The court held the provider was entitled to additional attorneys' fees under 11 NYCRR 65-4.10(j)(4) for services rendered in the article 75 proceeding itself, because a proceeding to confirm an arbitration award is a "court appeal" for purposes of that provision — following Matter of John T. Mather Memorial Hosp. v American Tr. Ins. Co., 247 AD3d 1188 [2026], and Matter of GEICO Ins. Co. v AAAMG Leasing Corp., 148 AD3d 703, 705 [2017]. The fee for winning the arbitration and the fee for going to court to make the carrier honor it are two separate recoveries, and the second is not capped by the first.

The procedural trap is in how the second fee is proven. The Supreme Court had correctly directed the provider to submit an affirmation of attorneys' fees for the court to fix an amount — and then the judgment issued with no such award and, on the record, no apparent basis for the omission. The Appellate Division took judicial notice that the affirmation had in fact been filed with the proposed judgment on NYSCEF, and noted the record had been certified under CPLR 2105. Where a carrier defaults and a judgment is submitted on notice, the fee affirmation has to go up with the proposed judgment and the filing has to be verifiable afterward.

For a no-fault receivable this reorders the collection file. A master arbitration award is not the end of the matter and an unopposed petition is not a guarantee of a complete judgment: diary the date of the master award, confirm it, and then read the entered judgment line by line against both regulations — 65-4.6(d) for the capped arbitration fee and 65-4.10(j)(4) for the court-proceeding fee — before the file is closed as collected. A judgment that is short on either line is an appealable error, and here it took until 2026 to correct a judgment entered in January 2024.

Source: Matter of Integrated Specialty ASC, LLC v American Tr. Ins. Co., 2026 NY Slip Op 02651 [248 AD3d 1245]  ·  View official page ↗  ·  Summarized by MagendaMD.

← Back to The Billing Ledger