One Arbitration's Verification Finding Can Bind the Carrier in the Next
The carrier denied the claim, the provider arbitrated, and the arbitrator awarded the full amount — applying collateral estoppel to conclude, on the basis of a prior arbitration determination, that failure to comply with additional verification requests was not a valid basis for the denial. The master arbitrator affirmed the March 25, 2022 award. Supreme Court, Kings County vacated it, and a clerk's judgment entered April 18, 2024 granted the carrier's petition. On May 20, 2026 the Second Department reversed, denied the petition, and confirmed the master arbitration award.
The reasoning is about how narrow the carrier's exit is once a master arbitrator has ruled. A court reviewing a master arbitrator's award in compulsory no-fault arbitration is limited to the CPLR article 75 grounds, which here reduce to whether the determination had evidentiary support, was rational, or had a plausible basis. The master arbitrator's own review power is broader than the courts' because it includes review for errors of law; the courts "generally will not vacate an arbitrator's award where the error claimed is the incorrect application of a rule of substantive law, unless it is so irrational as to require vacatur." The panel found the master arbitrator's determination rational and supported by evidence, and that ended the inquiry.
The billing consequence sits in the phrase prior arbitration determination. A finding that a practice did comply with a carrier's additional verification requests — or that the requests were not a valid basis for denial — is not spent when that case closes. It is a record the practice can carry into the next dispute with the same carrier on the same facts. That only works if the record is retrievable: keep the award itself, the AAA case number, the award date, the arbitrator's name, and the specific verification requests and responses the finding rested on, filed by carrier rather than buried in the claim file it came from.
The fee tail is worth knowing before deciding whether a confirmation proceeding is worth bringing. The Second Department remitted for a determination of reasonable attorney's fees, other fees, costs and disbursements under 11 NYCRR 65-4.6(h) and 11 NYCRR 65-4.10(j)(4). Read that against the fee ruling reported here in April: a proceeding to confirm an arbitration award counts as a "court appeal" for 65-4.10(j)(4) purposes, and the arbitration-and-master-arbitration fee under 65-4.6(d) is capped at $1,360, not the $1,000 a court had awarded. Where a carrier litigates a confirmed award into court and loses, the fee exposure runs past the 20-percent arbitration fee.