No-Fault · Arbitration

A De Novo Suit That Dies on Discovery Brings the Master Award Back to Life — With Fees

October 21, 2026  ·  New York

An acupuncture provider won a master arbitration award dated April 20, 2022. The carrier, American Transit, then commenced an action in Supreme Court, Kings County under Insurance Law § 5106(c) for a de novo determination of the claims — the step that ordinarily takes an award out of the collection queue. The carrier's complaint was later stricken for failure to comply with a conditional discovery order, and the provider moved to confirm the award and for attorneys' fees. By order dated June 20, 2024, Supreme Court denied both. On October 21, 2026 the Appellate Division, Second Department reversed and granted both branches.

The holding a billing office needs is about the award's status while the carrier's suit is pending. The court held that commencing the de novo action "did not eliminate the master arbitration award but only placed it in a dormant state," and that the dismissal for discovery noncompliance "revived the master arbitration award and made it binding on the parties." Confirmation was therefore required. A file in which the carrier has sued de novo is not a lost file; it is a suspended one, and it should stay open with the master award and its date preserved.

The second holding is the fee. Because the provider was seeking payment of overdue claims, the court held it was entitled to attorneys' fees under 11 NYCRR 65-4.10(j)(4) for services necessarily performed in connection with the de novo action, and for the appeal, and remitted the matter to Supreme Court, Kings County to fix a reasonable amount. Read with the April decision in Integrated Specialty ASC, which treated a proceeding to confirm as a "court appeal" carrying its own fee, the court-stage fee now reaches defending a carrier's de novo suit as well, not just confirming an uncontested award.

In practice: diary every de novo action a carrier files against a master award, track its docket for dismissal — including for failure to prosecute or to comply with discovery — and move to confirm as soon as it is dismissed. Keep counsel's time records from the de novo action, because those services are what the 65-4.10(j)(4) fee is fixed from. The decision is uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.

Source: American Tr. Ins. Co. v Bliss Acupuncture, P.C., 2026 NY Slip Op 06081 (App Div, 2d Dept)  ·  View official page ↗  ·  Summarized by MagendaMD.

← Back to The Billing Ledger