No-Fault · Verification

Mailing the Documents Is Not Enough When Your Own Affidavit Contradicts the Address

October 7, 2026  ·  New York

A Kings County Civil Court decision dated September 24, 2026, reported October 7, dismissed a physical therapy clinic's no-fault reimbursement claim with prejudice. State Farm had demanded management agreements, W-2 forms, bank records and lease agreements under 11 NYCRR 65-3.5(o), and the clinic did not produce them within the 120-day verification period. The report describes the decision as uncorrected and open to revision or appeal, and it comes from a trial-level court, so treat it as a warning rather than settled law.

The clinic's defense was that its owner had mailed the documents to the address on State Farm's letters. But the owner's affidavit itself listed a Phoenix, Arizona PO Box, while the carrier's letters directed documents to Concordville, Pennsylvania. Without corroborating proof of mailing, the court found the contradiction undermined the affidavit. Read against the proof-of-mailing rule on the carrier's side, this is the other half: the carrier must show the request went out, and the provider must be able to show the response did.

The court also considered the Court of Appeals' 2025 Mayzenberg principle and found it inapplicable. According to the report, that principle applies only after an insurer has finished its investigation and made a conclusive finding of professional misconduct. A provider that never answered the verification requests never reaches that stage, and the 120-day deadline still controls.

What to do differently: answer every verification letter to the exact address printed on it, and log the date, the address used and the method. Keep a certified-mail receipt, fax confirmation or portal acknowledgment, and make sure any later affidavit about the mailing matches those records, including the return address. Calendar the 120 days from the first request, and where a document cannot be produced, say so in writing before the clock runs out.

Source: Insurance Business — Civil Court, Kings County (Burke 2 Physical Therapy v State Farm)  ·  View official page ↗  ·  Summarized by MagendaMD.

← Back to The Billing Ledger