Suspected Auto-Fraud Reports Hit 43,811 — Up 80% Since 2020
New York's fraud problem now has a number attached to it. Insurance carriers reported 43,811 incidents of suspected motor-vehicle insurance fraud in 2025 — an 80% increase since 2020 — a surge that has moved no-fault fraud from an industry complaint to a policy priority.
The reported spike is the backdrop for a wave of enforcement: staged-accident rings dismantled in civil court, criminal charges against crash stagers, and large RICO suits by carriers against alleged durable-medical-equipment mills. The 43,811 figure is a big part of why all of that is happening at once.
Governor Hochul's auto-insurance reform proposal responds directly to the trend. It seeks to criminalize staged accidents outright, grant prosecutors new authority to pursue the organizers of fraud rings, and strengthen the state's ability to disqualify and penalize medical providers who participate in fraudulent billing.
The reform dovetails with the workers'-compensation side, where the FY27 budget funds dedicated district-attorney anti-fraud units. Together they signal a coordinated state posture: more investigators, tougher penalties, and less tolerance for the billing patterns fraud rings rely on.
For legitimate practices the implication is practical rather than punitive. As enforcement scales up, carriers scrutinize verification, medical necessity, and pricing more aggressively across the board. The billers who stay clean, timely, and well-documented are the ones who keep getting paid while the mills get squeezed.