Priority-of-Payment Defense Loses Its Teeth in Arbitration
In a line of decisions, the First and Second Departments have held that the priority-of-payment rule at 11 NYCRR 65-3.15 has no force or effect in arbitration. That sounds technical, but for the economics of no-fault it is significant.
The priority-of-payment rule governs the order in which claims are paid out of a policy's limited benefits. Insurers have long used it as a defense — arguing that a given bill should not be paid, or should be reduced, because of how the policy's benefits were or should have been allocated among competing providers.
Here is why the ruling bites: the large majority of no-fault disputes are resolved through arbitration, not court litigation. So holding that the rule has no force in arbitration effectively removes priority of payment as a practical defense in most of the cases that actually get fought. A defense that does not work in the forum where disputes are decided is, functionally, not much of a defense.
For providers, that tilts the field toward the fundamentals of the bill itself. With one common insurer argument off the table, arbitrators increasingly turn on the questions providers can actually control: was the bill filed on time, was verification answered, and is the medical necessity documented.
The strategic takeaway is that clean, timely, well-documented bills carry even more weight than before. This is not an invitation to relax — insurers still contest necessity, coding, and timeliness aggressively — but it does mean that a provider who nails the basics has a stronger position in arbitration than the raw dollar amounts might suggest.