No-Fault · EUO

The First Transcript Justifies the Second EUO — and a Day-Before Email Does Not Excuse the No-Show

November 6, 2026  ·  New York

A physical therapy provider sued State Farm over $639.85 in bills for treatment on May 8, May 30, June 3 and June 17–18, 2024, following a February 7, 2024 accident. The assignor sat for an examination under oath by videoconference on May 29, 2024, with a Spanish interpreter, for about four hours. Near the end, defense counsel asked on the record for a continued EUO because there had not been time to question the assignor about the accident and the treatment: the agreed 4 PM end time had arrived, and a 20-minute lunch had stretched past 50 minutes. The assignor's representative did not object. On November 6, 2026, the Civil Court, Bronx County granted State Farm summary judgment and dismissed the complaint in its entirety.

State Farm sent continuation notices dated June 7 and June 27, 2024, scheduling the continued EUO for June 27 and then July 25. The day before the first date, a paralegal for the assignor's attorneys emailed that the assignor "won't be able to make it," with no reason and no alternative dates. The day before the second, she wrote that she "can't locate" him. He appeared on neither date, and State Farm issued a global denial on August 14, 2024. Under 11 NYCRR 65-3.5(e), the court held that "the transcript itself constitutes documentary proof of the specific objective justification for the continued EUO," and that the no-shows were a breach of a condition precedent vitiating coverage. Of the day-before messages it said: "Such vague and untimely assertions do not constitute reasonable justification under the regulations."

The point for a billing office is that a continued EUO is not a fresh demand the carrier has to justify from nothing. Where the first session's transcript shows why it could not be finished, that transcript carries the carrier's burden. The court noted that the First and Second Departments differ on whether an insurer moving on an EUO no-show must set out its justification for the EUO in its papers, and it expressly left open whether a carrier must justify an initial EUO the claimant attended without objection. A collection strategy built on attacking the carrier's reasons is therefore weakest exactly where a continuance is in play. And the denial reached every bill on the claim, including dates of service before the first missed appearance.

What to do differently: when a carrier schedules an EUO for a patient whose bills you are carrying, diary every continuation date, not just the first one, and confirm attendance with the assignor's attorneys well ahead of each. A rescheduling request belongs in writing before the date, with a reason and alternative dates; a cancellation the day before, with no reason, did not save these bills. Ask for the transcript of any session that ends with a continuance on the record, because that is the document the court relied on. This is a trial-level decision, uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.

Source: 360 Wellness PT PLLC v State Farm Ins. Co., 2026 NY Slip Op 26206 (Civ Ct, Bronx County)  ·  View official page ↗  ·  Summarized by MagendaMD.

← Back to The Billing Ledger