Allstate and GEICO Escalate No-Fault Fraud Suits in New York
Two of the largest auto insurers have sharply intensified their legal campaign against alleged no-fault fraud in New York, and the pattern of filings suggests a coordinated, sustained push rather than one-off cases.
Allstate filed two federal lawsuits under the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO), charging that 10 durable-medical-equipment (DME) companies and 9 individuals orchestrated a 'medical mill' built to exploit the state's no-fault system. Across those actions Allstate identified more than $1 million already paid out and roughly $1.1 million in claims still pending — money it argues never should have been billed.
The filings kept coming. On June 30, Allstate brought four additional suits accusing New York medical-equipment suppliers of running a no-fault billing scheme. GEICO, separately, sued 11 New York DME companies and an alleged hidden owner over a purported $10 million scheme. DME has become a recurring target because it is high-margin, easy to over-bill, and often routed through opaque ownership structures.
The insurers' through-line is economic: they argue these schemes inflate premiums for every New York driver, which is also the political argument for tougher enforcement. Paired with the state's new district-attorney anti-fraud units, the civil suits form a two-front campaign — private litigation plus criminal referral.
For legitimate providers, none of this is an accusation, but it is a warning about the operating environment. The enforcement wave raises the stakes on verified ownership, genuine and documented medical necessity, and clean paperwork on every no-fault bill. As carriers grow more aggressive, the practices that look nothing like the mills — transparent ownership, real clinical documentation, correct pricing — are the ones that move through the system with the least resistance.