Verification Defense Still Needs Proof the Request Went Out
A 2026 decision has restated the evidentiary burden on carriers that defend a no-fault claim on unanswered verification. Regulation 68 lets an insurer demand "all items necessary to verify the claim" under 11 NYCRR 65-3.5(c), and an unanswered demand can be fatal to a provider's claim — but the carrier has to prove the demand was actually made.
To prevail on summary judgment, the court held, an insurer must show evidence that the verification requests were sent, that the recipient failed to provide the requested information, and that no reasonable justification was offered for the failure. Asserting that verification went unanswered is not the same as establishing it, and a defective mailing record undoes the defense before the merits are reached.
Read against the 120-day withdrawal rule, the two fit together rather than conflict. Silence can indeed extinguish a claim — but only where the predicate demand was properly issued in the first place. The clock does not start on a request the carrier cannot show it sent.
For providers the operational lesson is symmetrical. Keep proof of what you sent and when: date-stamped responses, fax confirmations, mail logs. Where a carrier claims silence and you in fact answered, your own record is what defeats the defense — and where you genuinely missed a demand, a documented reasonable justification is the remaining avenue.