No-Fault · Case Law

A Denial Is Only as Good as the Proof It Was Mailed — Even Across a Corporate Merger

June 8, 2026  ·  New York

A Kings County Civil Court has denied a carrier summary judgment on an EUO no-show defense — not because the examinations under oath were improperly scheduled, but because the carrier could not prove in admissible form that it mailed the denials. In UGP Acupuncture, P.C. v Ameriprise Ins. Co., decided June 8, 2026 by Hon. Sandra E. Roper, the defense rested on EUOs noticed for February 15, 2019 and March 8, 2019, against dates of service running December 5, 2018 through February 13, 2019 and denials dated March 13 and March 15, 2019. The defense collapsed on the mailing affidavit.

The gap the court identified is one that recurs across aged no-fault files: the affidavit was executed in 2022 and described the affiant's current employer, while the mailings it had to prove happened in 2019. The affiant worked for American Family Insurance Claims Services, Inc.; the policy had been underwritten by American Family Connect Insurance Company, formerly Ameriprise Insurance Company; and as of February 1, 2021 the affiant's position had been transferred between entities, with the affidavit asserting that her duties, responsibilities and procedures remained the same. The court held that the relevant mailing practices are the practices that existed in 2019, and that an assertion of continuity written three years later does not establish them.

What was missing is the useful part of the decision, because it is a checklist. The carrier submitted no documentary proof of the transition itself, no proof of the transfer or incorporation of the predecessor's records, no evidence of continuity of mailing procedures, no identification of the personnel responsible for mailing in 2019, no 2019 mailing manuals or procedures, no mailing logs, no certificates of mailing, and no claims-system conversion records. The court called the repeated assertion that the same practices were used conclusory, and added that using one collective corporate name for several related entities does not by itself establish that each maintained identical mailing procedures or that the predecessor's records were properly incorporated as business records.

The other half of the ruling is the half a billing office should act on. The plaintiff's motion was granted to the extent that it established its prima facie case as to the timely and proper mailing of the bills, and the carrier's remaining defenses were left to proceed to trial. The standard runs both ways, and the provider met it. That is what a mailing record is for: the controlling test is proof that the claim, on the statutory billing form, was mailed to and received by the insurer — established by an affiant with personal knowledge of the office's actual mailing practice, not by an attorney affirmation and not by a description of how the office works today.

Two practical items follow. First, on any file where the payer entity or its administrator has changed names or hands between the date of service and the litigation, capture and preserve the payer identity as it appeared on the denial at the time — the entity mismatch is now a live defect the carrier must cure, and it is your record of the original denial that exposes it. Second, this is the same evidentiary principle a court applied to a verification defense in Medical Supply of NY Direct Servs. Corp. v State Farm: a defense that depends on a piece of paper having been sent fails when the carrier cannot prove it went out. Denials and verification requests are now being measured by the same yardstick, and the practice that keeps a clean, contemporaneous submission and receipt log is the one holding the better half of it.

Source: UGP Acupuncture, P.C. v Ameriprise Ins. Co., 2026 NY Slip Op 32085(U) (Civ Ct, Kings County)  ·  View official page ↗  ·  Summarized by MagendaMD.

← Back to The Billing Ledger